domenica 23 febbraio 2014

EU Financial Assistance Conditionality after 'Two Pack'


Michael Ioannidis 


Goethe University Frankfurt - Faculty of Law; Max Planck Institute for Comparative Public Law and International Law

February 20, 2014

Abstract:      
Conditionality is the new topos of EU economic governance. In Pringle, the ECJ raised “strict conditionality” to a necessary requirement of assistance to Members in financial distress, and after the recent amendment of Article 136 TFEU this is also explicitly set out in the Treaties. Moreover, conditionality proved to be an extremely powerful instrument. It has been used to press for reforms in recipient countries’ economies, healthcare and pension systems, education and research. On many occasions, the conditions for accessing European financing are prescribed in minute detail. Never before had European institutions been engaged in so close surveillance and micromanagement of domestic public policies. Starting from these observations, this article has two purposes. Firstly, to shed some light to the origins and the mechanics of EU financial assistance conditionality, and, secondly, to offer a critical appraisal of its role in the context of the new EU economic governance, especially after the so-called “Two Pack” set of reforms. Although Regulation 472/2013/EU succeeds in putting all forms of conditional lending under a common EU framework, it fails to address the basic concerns raised by the emergence of conditionality as a cornerstone of EU economic governance. Blurred responsibility, wide executive discretion, and uncertainty as to the legal instruments are some of the points that remain problematic.

Number of Pages in PDF File: 44

Towards Global Social Theory


Björn Hettne 


Göteborg University - School of Global Studies

Fredrik Söderbaum 


University of Gothenburg, School of Global Studies; United Nations University, Institute on Comparative Regional Integration Studies (UNU-CRIS)

1999

Journal of International Relations and Development, Vol. 2, No. 4. pp. 358-368, 1999 

Abstract:      
Our purpose is to take stock of some current trends in the rethinking of development theory, but above all to transcend the development discourse and move towards a comprehensive social science theory, here called ‘global social theory’, meaning a unified historical and critical social science that moves beyond the pitfalls of state-centrism and an obsession with ‘national development’. In a turbulent and ‘globalised’ world, the nation-state no longer constitutes the dominant framework for understanding society, and social processes must be analysed delinked from national space. It is argued that certain strands of international political economy (IPE) theory and certain strands of development theory, in conjunction with a new emphasis on cultural studies as well as the new development-related conflicts, together constitute possible building blocks of a reconstruction of development theory, as a step towards global social theory.
Number of Pages in PDF File: 20
Keywords: social theory, globalization, developent theory, IPE
Accepted Paper Series 

Full text available at: http://papers.ssrn.com/sol3/papers.cfm?abstract_id=2399203

Politicizing Europe: The Challenge of Executive Discretion


Jonathan White 


London School of Economics & Political Science (LSE)

February 21, 2014

LEQS Paper No. 72 

Abstract:      
Political decision-making in the Euro-crisis has relied heavily on executive discretion, exercised at speed and rationalised with reference to the pressing demands of emergency. This paper explores the challenges raised for political opposition, notably challenges of a temporal kind. With its deviations from policy and procedural norms, discretionary politics tends towards a politics without rhythm, leading to major asymmetries between decision-makers and voices of opposition. These centre on issues of timing and the ability to identify authorship and content of decisions. Such asymmetries arguably correspond to an underlying one between the temporality of political decision-making and of contemporary finance capitalism, with agents of the former increasingly inclined to pursue ‘fast policy’ as a means to keep pace. A democratic response is likely to involve strengthening and synchronising the rhythms of parliamentary politics, as well as being receptive to forms of opposition less reliant on the rhythms that discretion subverts.
Number of Pages in PDF File: 28
Keywords: politicization, democracy, time, executive power, European Union

JEL Classification: Z00

A Right to Cultural Identity in a UK Bill of Rights?


Elizabeth Craig 


University of Sussex

April 29, 2013

European Public Law, Vol. 19, p. 789, 2013 

Abstract:      
This article considers the possible inclusion of a right to cultural identity in a UK Bill of Rights, highlighting the centrality of culture to debates about the accommodation of diversity in the UK as well as the increased recognition of the importance of cultural rights under international human rights law. The article argues that the inclusion of a minimal minority rights guarantee based on Article 27 of the International Covenant on Civil and Political Rights 1966 would be an innocuous step that would provide the impetus needed for greater cultural sensitivity in decision-making processes in a way that acknowledges the centrality of culture to people's identities and everyday lives. It claims that the inclusion of such a right alongside a freestanding right to equality would provide a useful addition to the rights currently recognized as 'Convention rights' under the UK Human Rights Act 1998. This is argued on the basis of both international and domestic case law, including opinions of the UN Human Rights Committee, developments in European human rights law and experiences in other jurisdictions.
Number of Pages in PDF File: 32

Keywords: cultural rights, minority rights, cultural identity, bill of rights, cultural diversity

martedì 18 febbraio 2014

PHD Persona e tutele giuridiche

Lezione Magistrale
Prof. ANDRAS SAJO (European Court of Human Rights)

How International Human Rights Protection can be: The example of the European Court of Human Rights

 24 febbraio 2014, ore 10.30
Aula Magna Storica
Scuola Superiore Sant’Anna
Piazza Martiri della Libertà, 33 - Pisa

lunedì 10 febbraio 2014

Unione europea e good governance: seminari integrativi (Università di Pisa, Prof. Sara Poli)

Il corso Unione europea e good governance (laurea magistrale in Studi Internazionali, LM 52) organizza due seminari integrativi in lingua inglese.

Il primo seminario, Good governance in EU external relations, è tenuto dal Prof. Dr. Jan Wouters (Jean Monnet Chair ad personam EU and Global Governance; Full Professor of International Law and International Organizations; Director, Leuven Centre for Global Governance Studies - Institute for International Law, Università di Lovanio). Si svolgerà martedì 25 febbraio 2014, alle 10.30, aula M2 - polo Piagge

http://www.sp.unipi.it/images/webmaster/WOUTERS_locandina-def.pdf


Il secondo seminario, The European Ombudsman and the right to good administration as a fundamental right: conceptual issues, sarà tenuto dal dr. Antonis Antoniadis, funzionario del mediatore europeo. Si svolgerà venerdì 6 marzo 2014, alle ore 15, aula N2 - polo Piagge.

http://www.sp.unipi.it/images/webmaster/Antoniadis_locandina.pdf


venerdì 24 gennaio 2014

Why are Americans Originalist?


Jack M. Balkin 


Yale University - Law School

January 14, 2014

LAW, SOCIETY AND COMMUNITY: SOCIO-LEGAL ESSAYS IN HONOUR OF ROGER COTTERRELL, David Schiff and Richard Nobles, eds. (Ashgate Publishing, 2015 Forthcoming) 

Abstract:      
This brief essay, addressed to scholars outside the United States, attempts to explain why originalism is popular in debates over the American federal Constitution. If as its advocates sometimes maintain, originalism is the most legitimate method of interpretation in a democracy, one would expect advocates in every constitutional democracy in the world to demand that judges use it. Yet although originalism has made inroads in Australia and a few other countries, it is largely ignored elsewhere in the world. Although the “thin” version of original meaning advocated in Living Originalism would not be particularly controversial in most constitutional democracies, "thicker" versions of originalism that require judges to follow how a constitution's adopters would have understood or applied the text have little influence outside the United States or even in the interpretation of the fifty indigenous state constitutions. Originalism’s authority in debates about the American federal Constitution rests on cultural factors rather than a unique American commitment to the rule of law or popular sovereignty.

American originalism is primarily a nationalist idea. It arises from distinctive features of American cultural memory -- namely, that in popular imagination the American nation was created by Americans themselves through a self-conscious act of political revolution, and that the American nation, people, and constitution came into being more or less simultaneously through this initial act of self-creation. A similar story is not told in most other political cultures. This story has helped encourage Americans’ special veneration of the founding generation and particular figures within that generation (like George Washington and James Madison) as culture heroes.

The self-conscious invocation of originalism as a general theory of interpretation is relatively recent; it is a response to constitutional modernity, in which Americans found themselves increasingly distanced from the past and sought to justify political reforms. Academic theories of originalism proliferated in American law schools in response to the political uses of originalism in the twentieth century. Yet as these theories have become increasingly sophisticated there is often little connection between them, the popular uses of originalism, and the way that originalist arguments are actually deployed (or ignored) by practicing lawyers and judges.

Americans use originalism as a political practice for critiquing the status quo (whether in a liberal or conservative direction) and arguing for change, sometimes quite radical. Appeals to origins serve as a precedent-breaking device -- they help justify a break from current practices by appealing to an even older tradition. This explains a little-understood fact about American originalism. The originators of originalism as a self-conscious approach to interpretation were not movement conservatives -- they were New Deal liberals. The increase in citations to originalist materials in Supreme Court opinions begins with Justice Hugo Black and the Warren Court. New Deal liberals committed to judicial restraint needed a way to justify exercising judicial review to protect individual rights. They turned to history to do so. Movement conservatives, who sought to break from liberal precedents, then flipped the political valence of originalism; they were so successful that originalism's origins as a liberal justificatory device have largely been forgotten.
Number of Pages in PDF File: 29

Keywords: Originalism, interpretation, constitution, American culture, cultural memory, culture heroes, modernity