domenica 23 febbraio 2014

The Court of Justice's Participation in the Judicial Discourse: Theory and Practice


Christina Eckes 


Amsterdam Centre for European Law and Governance

February 17, 2014

Marise Cremona & Anne Thies (eds.), The European Court of Justice and External Relations - Constitutional Challenges (Hart Publishing, Oxford, 2014) 

Abstract:      
Judges argue within a legal frame of reference. They identify and interpret this frame and read factual situations before them in the light of it. By interpreting the law and the facts coherently with the relevant legal frame of reference they aim to objectively justify their decisions. This may sound naïve and often be much less heroic in practice. However, the core value of separation of powers and of independent judicial review is widely accepted, including the added value of the judiciary’s attempts to objectify what is ‘just’ outside of the political power struggle. Judicial discourse, it is here argued, could help the judiciary to continue to offer this objectifying value in a pluricontextual setting, where the internal and the external become increasingly interlocked because policy making is increasingly externalized, rights relevant decisions are taken by the executive outside the domestic constitutional framework, and an increasing number of players claim authority, including ultimate authority, to govern a legal situation.

The chapter hopes to contribute to the thinking about the role of the judiciary in a pluricontextual setting and turns to the European Union (EU) for inspiration. Within the EU the relationship between EU law on the one hand and the Member States collectively and individually on the other is characterized by an on-going pulling and pushing of law and politics. Both the Court of Justice of the European Union (CJEU) and Member States’ courts have long functioned in this setting. The Union legal order is a compound constitutionalized construction with interlocking claims of ultimate authority. This chapter considers what could be learned from interaction between different judiciaries within the EU legal order for the CJEU’s approach to external claims of authority.

Section One lays out the theoretical grounding of the value and necessity of judicial reasoning. It then makes the argument that both within the EU and beyond the boundaries of the EU legal order, the same philosophical arguments and theories require not only an inward looking judicial reasoning but also a discourse with other judicial bodies. Section Two looks consequently into the practice of judicial interaction between the CJEU and the courts of the Member States (internal discourse) and then to the interaction between the CJEU and international judicial bodies (external discourse). This sets the scene for Section Three, which addresses the core questions of this chapter: What lessons can the CJEU learn from the internal European judicial discourse that can be transferred to the external discourse with international courts and tribunals? What considerations should guide the CJEU’s external relations case law in the described pluricontextual setting?
Number of Pages in PDF File: 28

Keywords: Judicial discourse; European Union; Court of Justice

Kant, Human Rights and Courts


Andreas Follesdal 


University of Oslo; University of Oslo - Norwegian Centre for Human Rights; Pluricourts

2013

Kantian Theory and Human Rights, eds. Andreas Follesdal and Reidar Maliks: Routledge. 2014, 193-202
PluriCourts Research Paper No. 14-05 

Abstract:      
It is, perhaps, not by chance that the steep increase in theories of human rights has been matched by a renaissance in studies of Kant’s political philosophy. The essays are animated by the idea that if we get a better grip on Kant’s philosophy of right, we can energize the creative endeavor of developing philosophical theories of human rights, inspired by his particular way of thinking about the relation between rights and the rule of law. Three features characteristic of Kant’s thinking frequently crop up in the following chapters and help explain why so much recent scholarship may indeed properly be called ‘Kantian’. These features concern rights, legitimacy, and institutions. freedom is constituted by the rights and duties that enable individuals to be subject to the rule of law instead of arbitrary power. Second, political and legal authorities that establish human rights through law derive their legitimacy from being capable of justification to individuals. Third, the public institutions at the domestic and the international level are considered part of the same system. The contributions explore these Kantian principles in different directions.

Number of Pages in PDF File: 12

Fragile Democracies, Strong Human Rights Courts? Comparing European and Inter-American Cases


Leiry Cornejo Chavez 


University of Oslo - Norwegian Centre for Human Rights

Andreas Follesdal 


University of Oslo; University of Oslo - Norwegian Centre for Human Rights; Pluricourts

December 1, 2013

Nordic Journal of Human Rights, 2013, No. 4
PluriCourts Research Paper No. 14-03 

Abstract:      
Do regional Human Rights Courts strengthen democracy? If so, when and why does this occur: what are the scope conditions and intervening mechanisms that make such courts have positive effects? The articles in this special section address these questions as regards the European Court of Human Rights (ECtHR) and the Inter-American Court of Human Rights (IACtHR). Their similarities and differences allow several lessons to be drawn about the relationship between such courts and democracy.

Number of Pages in PDF File: 5

Much Ado About Nothing? International Judicial Review of Human Rights in Well Functioning Democracies


Andreas Follesdal 


University of Oslo; University of Oslo - Norwegian Centre for Human Rights; Pluricourts

2014

The Legitimacy of International Human Rights Regimes. A. Follesdal, J. Schaffer and G. Ulfstein. Cambridge, Cambridge University Press, 272-299
PluriCourts Research Paper No. 14-04 

Abstract:      
The chapter addresses some of the tensions between sovereignty, international human rights review and legitimacy, and bring these findings to bear on the proposals for reform of the European Court of Human Rights (ECtHR) that would reduce its authority over national legislatures and judiciaries. The objectives of such review are not obvious, the causes of noncompliance are contested, as is the legality of dynamic treaty interpretation; all of which hamper efforts to assess proposed improvements. Section 1 presents some relevant aspects of the ECtHR. Section 2 reviews some of the recent criticism against the ECtHR practice of judicial review to protect human rights in ‘well-functioning’ democracies, in terms of various forms of legitimacy deficits. It also presents some of the recent proposals for reform of the ECtHR. Section 3 lays out some reasons why such judicial review of majoritarian democratic decision-making may be defensible, also for well functioning democracies. Section 4 responds to some of the criticisms, and presents a partial defence. Some standard objections are not well targeted against the practices
of the ECtHR, partly due to the division of responsibility between it and national public bodies, and the different roles of legislators and of judiciaries. Section 5 returns to the proposals presented in section 2. Section 6 concludes by considering some of the important remaining normative challenges, this partial defence notwithstanding.

Number of Pages in PDF File: 27

Who Got to Adjudicate the EU's Financial Crisis and Why? Judicial Review of the Instruments of a Postnational Legal Order: Adjudicating the Practices of the Eurozone


Samo Bardutzky 


University of Michigan at Ann Arbor - University of Michigan Law School

Elaine Fahey 


Amsterdam Centre for European Law and Governance

May 15, 2013

Forthcoming in The Constitutionalization of European Budgetary Constraints First Edition Maurice Adams, Federico Fabbrini and Pierre Larouche (eds) (Oxford: Hart Publishing, 2014) 

Abstract:      
The European Stability Mechanism (“ESM”) is one of a series of law and governance mechanisms designed to finally resolve the Eurozone qua EU’s financial crisis, purporting to create an EU replica of the International Monetary Fund (“IMF”). Recently enacted law and governance mechanisms perform, cumulatively, a radical rebalancing of powers and functions. Whilst on the one hand, they purport to dramatically decrease Member State fiscal sovereignty through non-conventional and sometimes transitional instruments, on the other hand, they increase the capacity to protect the Eurozone through funds derived from the Member States themselves, albeit in shares apportioned relative to the size and financial capacity thereof. The account here argues that the adjudication of the ESM is a rich case study of the character of law in contemporary EU integration and the state of postnationalism. Moreover, the account here contends that it constitutes an example of suboptimal adjudication in the EU courts, plural, rooted in both the character of Eurozone law and a rather flawed procedural matrix for judicial review, in the form of the preliminary reference mechanism, pursuant to Article 267 TFEU. We seek to argue that courts possibly offered a unique forum for participation and contestation for these esoteric mechanisms, which was largely not availed of. Accordingly, in our analysis, first and foremost, we consider the characterization of the ESM, in light of how it was conceived by its framers. Secondly, we consider what happened when it was assessed by several European courts, national and supranational. Thirdly, we examine the preliminary reference mechanism as the tool that could have facilitated a more participatory and orchestrated judicial response, but did so to a very limited extent. We conclude by briefly considering the reasons why this happened, but focus our attention more generally upon the character of the ESM and its adjudication.
Number of Pages in PDF File: 18

Keywords: EU Institutional law, Eurozone law & governance, Preliminary reference, Judicial function, Postnationalism

The Financial Crisis: A Reason to Improve Shareholder Protection in the EU?


Jonathan Mukwiri 


Durham University - Durham Law School

Mathias M. Siems 


Durham University - Durham Law School; University of Cambridge - Centre for Business Research

November 1, 2013

Abstract:      
The global financial crisis of 2008 has stimulated the debate on corporate governance and shareholder protection. The intuitive reason for the topicality of shareholder protection is that insolvencies mainly harm shareholders as the companies’ residual claimants. In addition, ideally, shareholder empowerment may ensure better monitoring of management and therefore better-run companies preventing corporate failures and benefiting the economy as a whole. Yet, it is not self-evident that shareholder participation has such a positive effect. This paper critically examines the discussion about the relationship between the financial crisis, shareholder protection and law reform. We also develop a central position: while there may be a need to improve shareholder protection, we do not take the view that any increase in shareholder rights is the right way forward; rather, such reforms should aim to encourage shareholder engagement by responsible long-term investors.
Number of Pages in PDF File: 20

Keywords: shareholder protection, financial crisis, EU company law, long-term investors, shareholder engagement, institutional investors, shareholder activism

Economic and Fiscal Governance: The Hardening of European Soft Law


Holly Jarman 


University of Michigan

Scott L. Greer 


University of Michigan at Ann Arbor - Department of Health Management and Policy

February 16, 2014

Abstract:      
The European Union’s new architecture of fiscal and economic governance can be difficult to understand. How do two legislative packages, a treaty, a strategy and a “European Semester” interact to shape member state policies? This paper argues, on the basis of a review and presentation of the new fiscal governance architecture, that what we see is a hardening of European soft law. The new European Union fiscal governance involves both tougher and more automatic sanctions for states that violate the Stability and Growth Pact, and an expansion of mechanisms of surveillance and Commission involvement in member state economic and fiscal planning. The result is planned to combine the information and constant surveillance of soft law with the judicial enforceability and tough sanctions of hard law.
Number of Pages in PDF File: 45

Keywords: European Union, fiscal governance, economic governance, law, soft law, governance, fiscal policy