giovedì 22 maggio 2014

The Arab Spring's Four Seasons: International Protections and the Sovereignty Problem


Jillian Nicole Blake 


Independent

Aqsa Mahmud 


Independent

2014

Penn State Journal of Law & International Affairs, Vol. 3, No. 1, 2014 

Abstract:      
In December 2010, public demonstrations erupted throughout the Middle East against autocratic regimes, igniting a regional political transformation known as the Arab Spring. Depending on events, modern international criminal and humanitarian law provided certain protections to vulnerable populations. However, international law did not provide a uniform degree of protection to civilians and combatants who faced similar circumstances. This Article argues for a uniform standard of protections for all populations affected by armed conflict, war crimes, and crimes against humanity. It evaluates each of five major Arab Spring uprisings (Tunisia, Bahrain, Egypt, Syria, and Libya) and describes the legal protections that applied in each country’s revolution or rebellion. We analyze the differences in protection, focusing on the distinction between international and non-international armed conflicts under current international law, which affords a significantly lower degree of protection during civil conflicts. Given the substantial number of non-international armed conflicts in the modern era, we argue for a uniform standard of protections for all armed conflicts. Next, the Article shows that current sovereignty trends are moving away from the concept of an absolute sovereign in favor of a responsible sovereign who adheres to international standards. This trend is incompatible with current international law, which provides a minimal level of protection during civil war, and could therefore shield sovereigns from liability for mass atrocity crimes. Finally, this Article offers solutions to appropriately minimize outdated sovereignty norms and eliminate unjustified distinctions in the international legal system using lessons from the Arab Spring.
Number of Pages in PDF File: 56

Keywords: Arab Spring, Tunisia, Bahrain, Egypt, Syria, Libya

How Much Does EU Citizenship Cost? The Maltese Citizenship-for-Sale Affair: A Breakthrough for Sincere Cooperation in Citizenship of the Union?


Sergio Carrera 


Centre for European Policy Studies

April 25, 2014

Liberty and Security in Europe Paper No. 64 

Abstract:      
How much does European citizenship cost in the EU? This was the question that has raised so much controversy over the Maltese citizenship-for-sale programme. The outright selling of Maltese nationality to rich foreigners led to unprecedented responses by the European Parliament and European Commission. This paper examines the affair and its relevance for current and future configurations of citizenship of the EU. It studies the extent to which member states are still free to lay down the grounds for the acquisition and loss of nationality without any EU supervision and accountability. It provides a comparative overview of member state schemes and the exact price for buying citizenship and a residency permit in the EU. It is argued that the EU’s intervention on the Maltese citizenship-for-sale affair constitutes a legal precedent for assessing the lawfulness of passport-for-sale or golden migration programmes in other EU member states. The affair has also revealed the increasing relevance of a set of European and international legal principles limiting member states’ discretion over citizenship matters and providing a supranational constellation of accountability venues scrutinising the impact of their decisions over citizenship of the Union. The Maltese citizenship-for-sale affair has placed at the forefront the EU general principle of sincere cooperation in nationality matters. Member states’ actions in the citizenship domain cannot negatively affect in substance the concept and freedoms of European citizenship. That notwithstanding, the European institutions’ insistence on the need for Maltese nationality law to require a ‘genuine link’ in the form of an effective residence criteria for any rich applicants to benefit from the fast-track naturalisation poses a fundamental dilemma from the angle of Union citizenship: what is this genuine link really about? And what is precisely ‘habitual’, ‘effective’ or ‘functional’ residence? It is argued that by supporting the ‘real connections’ as the most relevant standard, the European institutions may be paradoxically fuelling nationalistic misuses by member states of the ‘genuine link’ as a way to justify restrictive integration policies on the acquisition of nationality.
Number of Pages in PDF File: 54

Keywords: European citizenship, EU, Maltese citizenship-for-sale affair

Pouvoir Constituant and Pouvoir Irritant in the Postnational Order


Nico Krisch 


Institució Catalana de Recerca i Estudis Avançats - ICREA; Institut Barcelona d'Estudis Internacionals - IBEI

April 28, 2014

Abstract:      
Constituent power is a key concept of the modern constitutional tradition, yet it encounters serious difficulties when transposed into today’s globalized world. Its radical promise sits uneasily with a social and political context that seems out of reach and impossible to ‘constitute’. Yet the idea of constituent power continues to animate people in their efforts to reclaim agency and self-government in a landscape shaped largely by others. This paper traces key challenges to the continuing force of constituent power, both in the domestic and the global contexts, and it offers an account in which constituent power in the postnational order survives only in part, as a mere irritant of existing institutional structures. This reduced role points to the limitations of a ‘global constitutionalism’ which is typically confined to providing liberal checks while marginalizing strong aspirations of self-government.
Number of Pages in PDF File: 21

Keywords: constitutionalism; constituent power; globalization; postnational law; global governance

Proportionality in Fundamental Rights Conflicts in National Measures Implementing EU Law


Pekka Savola 


University of Helsinki

April 30, 2014

Abstract:      
In this paper, proportionality and balancing of fundamental rights conflicts in national measures implementing EU law are examined. Different contexts of proportionality evaluation and fundamental rights are identified, with the focus on the aforementioned conflicts. A five-step procedure is submitted for evaluating proportionality. The procedure entails identifying the context and depth of evaluation, identifying different parties' interests, identifying the principles and national law, formulating the concrete criteria used in evaluation, and finally applying the criteria in proportionality test. The procedure is illustrated with examples of intellectual property rights enforcement using faultless third-party intermediaries and in particular website blocking orders.
Number of Pages in PDF File: 23

Keywords: proportionality, balancing, fundamental rights conflicts, IPR enforcement

The European Stability Mechanism through the Legal Meanderings of the Union's Constitutionalism: Comment on Pringle


Stanislas Adam 


Ghent University-Universiteit Gent

Francisco Javier Mena Parras 


Université Libre de Bruxelles (ULB) - Institute of European Studies; Free University of Brussels (VUB) - Research Group Fundamental Rights & Constitutionalism

May 4, 2014

(Draft version) European Law Review, 2013, 38 (6), pp. 848-865 

Abstract:      
In its judgment in Pringle, delivered on November 27, 2012, the Court of Justice of the European Union upheld the establishment of the European Stability Mechanism through the conclusion of an international agreement by Euro Area Member States. Beyond its implications for the Union’s economic and monetary policy, this landmark judgment offers food for thought on a series of central issues in EU constitutional law, including the scope of the simplified revision procedure in art. 48 (6) TEU or Member State co-operation and the use of EU institutions outside the EU legal order. It also constitutes a unique illustration of multi-level dialogue in the European Union in the post-Lisbon era.
Number of Pages in PDF File: 19

Keywords: Constitutionality, Economic and monetary policy, EU law, European Stability Mechanism, Ireland, Sovereign debt, Treaties, Validity


Proportionality and the Rule of Law: Rights, Justification, Reasoning


Grant Huscroft 


University of Western Ontario - Faculty of Law

Bradley W. Miller 


University of Western Ontario - Faculty of Law; James Madison Program in American Ideals and Institutions, Princeton University

Grégoire Webber 


London School of Economics - Law Department

April 21, 2014

PROPORTIONALITY AND THE RULE OF LAW: RIGHTS, JUSTIFICATION, REASONING, Grant Huscroft, Bradley W. Miller, and Grégoire Webber, eds., Cambridge University Press, 2014 

Abstract:      
Proportionality has been received into the constitutional doctrine of courts in Continental Europe, the United Kingdom, Canada, New Zealand, Israel, South Africa, and the United States, as well as the jurisprudence of treaty-based legal systems such as the European Convention on Human Rights.

Proportionality provides a common analytical framework for resolving the great moral and political questions confronting political communities. But behind the singular appeal to proportionality lurks a range of different understandings. This volume brings together many of the world's leading constitutional theorists – proponents and critics of proportionality – to debate the merits of proportionality, the nature of rights, the practice of judicial review, and moral and legal reasoning. Their essays provide important new perspectives on this leading doctrine in human rights law.

This is the Introduction to Proportionality and the Rule of Law: Rights, Justification, Reasoning, published by Cambridge University Press in April, 2014. In addition to the Introduction, this paper includes a list of contributors and a table of contents.
Number of Pages in PDF File: 27

Keywords: Constitutional theory, judicial review, proportionality, comparative constitutional law, constitutional rights, interpretation, rule of law,

Law and Development: 40 Years after Scholars in Self Estrangement - A Preliminary Review


David M. Trubek 


University of Wisconsin Law School

May 9, 2014

Univ. of Wisconsin Legal Studies Research Paper No. 1255 

Abstract:      
Noting that 2014 is the 40th anniversary of the publication of Scholars in Self-Estrangement, the author looks at the field of law and development during these four decades. In a preliminary report, he reviews the critique outlined in Scholars and the claim that its publication killed the field it was designed to save. While acknowledging that the field had lost momentum by 1980 he argues that the decline occurred not because of the article but because the field lost the support of development agencies before it could establish a secure place in the academy. Noting that the field revived in the late 1980s-early 1990s, he observes that conditions for law and development scholarship are much better today and there is a proliferation of research much of which has avoided errors pointed to in Scholars. This proliferation has enriched the field but at the price of fragmentation: the field has split into a number of “sub-disciplines” that do not always communicate with one another. The article scans the field in the 21st Century, noting the influence of new ideas about development which stress experimentation and local variation in policy. These, combined with a better understanding of the embeddness of local legal systems and the limits of legal transplants demands more attention to local context and variation. Looking to the future, the author concludes that if law and development is to produce useable knowledge the separate aspects of the field should be better integrated, more attention paid to local variation and context in law and policy, research capacity in the Global South enhanced, and North-South communication improved.
Number of Pages in PDF File: 33

Keywords: Law and Development, Transnational Law, Legal Education