giovedì 22 maggio 2014

Dysfunctional? Dissonant? Démodé? America’s Constitutional Woes in Comparative Perspective


Ran Hirschl 


University of Toronto - Faculty of Law

May 10, 2014

Boston University Law Review 94 (2014): 939-960 

Abstract:      
Much has been written in recent years about America’s political dysfunction, and whether it stems from, aided by or linked to systemic problems with the country’s constitutional order. In this article I place America’s constitutional shortcomings in a broader comparative context by considering them in light of four types of constitutional gridlock and dysfunction that are prevalent around the world. First, the “fundamental constitutional disharmony” scenario is characterized by discordant constitutional orders that disagree about the very definition and raison d’être of the polity as such, and fierce debate about sources of law and the form of government that result in an apparently oxymoronic constitutional framework (for example, Egypt, Israel, Pakistan, Malaysia, and Turkey). Second, the “synthetic constitution” scenario occurs where “artificial,” bi- or multi-ethnic polities live under a pragmatic, second-order, problem-solving, unprincipled constitutional mode that perpetually faces a realistic possibility of breakdown (for example, Belgium, Bosnia and Herzegovina, and perhaps also the pan-European constitutional order). Third, the “opportunistic constitutional wars” scenario features frequent political struggles and strategic quarrels between rival self-interested elites that are disguised as principled constitutional disagreements, and may occasionally escalate into all-out constitutional wars (for example, constitutional battles between rival political elites in Romania or the Philippines, and challenges to fiscal federalism and reallocation of resources in oil- or mineral-rich federations such as Bolivia or Nigeria). Finally, the “inadequate constitution” scenario - this occurs where there are dated or otherwise deficient constitutional designs that impede effective government and that may yield derisory political outcomes (for example, Italy has had sixty-two governments over the last sixty-seven years; the population in Canada’s 308 federal electoral ridings varies from 35,000 to over 125,000 so that a vote in certain parts of the country is “worth” 3.5 times more than a vote in other parts). When viewed through this comparative prism, the U.S. constitutional order seems to suffer from the latter, serious yet relatively lighter two problems, but not from the former, more life-threatening two.
Number of Pages in PDF File: 22

Keywords: America, United States, constitution, comparative constitutionalism, constitutional dysfunction

New Economic Governance in the European Union: Another Constitutional Battleground?


Fabian Amtenbrink 


Erasmus University Rotterdam - Erasmus School of Law

May 15, 2014

FORTHCOMING in K. Purnhagen and P. Roth (Eds.), Varieties of European Economic Law and Regulation, Heidelberg, Dordrecht, London, New York, Springer, 2014. 

Abstract:      
The European financial and euro area debt crisis has exposed fundamental flaws of the system of economic governance in the euro area and namely of the legal framework introduced into primary Union law by the 1992/1993 Treaty on European Union governing economic policy coordination. This crisis has triggered a European regulatory response, the scope and swiftness of which is unprecedented in the 60 year history of European integration. These regulatory activities raise serious constitutional questions not only at the supranational, European level, but mainly also at the level of the Member States that fuel the long-standing debate on the relationship between the supranational legal order and the (constitutional) legal orders of the Member States. As the focus in the national sphere is increasingly on the impact of the European regulatory activities on core structural principles of the constitutional legal orders and namely the structural principle of parliamentary democracy, this debate has every potential to become even more entrenched. This could also put the much referred to co-operation and dialogue between the national highest (constitutional) courts and the Court of Justice of the European Union to the tested yet again. This contribution commences with a brief flashback to the beginnings of European economic and monetary union highlighting that the current judicial discourse on European economic governance and its democratic credentials is anything but new, as it finds its roots in the Treaty on the European Union. Thereafter, an overview of the new legal framework pertaining to economic policy coordination in the euro area and its impact on the national policy sphere is provided, followed by an analysis of a selection of decisions by national highest (constitutional) courts and tribunals, thereby focusing on their dealing with the constitutional impact of various aspects of the European regulatory response to the crisis. In the concluding part a preliminary answer to the question raised in the title of this contribution is offered.
Number of Pages in PDF File: 40

Keywords: EU, Euro zone, euro, European Stability Mechanism, debt crisis, economic governance, European Semester, Six Pack, Two Pack, Fiscal Compact, national courts, European Court of Justice, principle of democracy, democratic legitimaction, European Parliament, national parliaments

The Curious Case of Overfitting Legal Transplants


Mathias M. Siems 


Durham University - Durham Law School; University of Cambridge - Centre for Business Research

May 15, 2014

in Maurice Adams and Dirk Heirbaut (eds.), The Method and Culture of Comparative Law: Essays in Honour of Mark Van Hoecke, Oxford: Hart Publishing, 2014, pp. 133-146. 

Abstract:      
Sometimes cultural phenomena are more popular abroad than at home. For example, modern business cards arrived in Japan in the late 19th century but in today’s Japan they are considered more important than in Western countries. Similarly, and even more surprisingly, in Germany the US actor David Hasselhoff is considered as one of the greatest pop stars while his musical career has not been very successful in the US. This chapter suggests that a similar phenomenon may also exist in law. This is meant to refer to the situation that legal transplants may work even ‘better’ in the transplant than in the origin country, here called ‘overfitting legal transplants’. This suggestion departs from the current debate about legal transplants which holds that, at best, a transplant may work almost as good as in the origin country (and, at worst, it may be irrelevant, or even harmful to the transplant country). Thus, it is the main aim of this paper to relate the idea of overfitting legal transplants to the current discussion, to outline possible categories and examples, and to show how law-makers may be able to make use of them.
Number of Pages in PDF File: 15

Keywords: legal transplants, comparative law, law and society, law and culture, business cards, David Hasselhoff, Big in Japan

Towards Effective Regulatory Cooperation Under TTIP: A Comparative Overview of the EU and US Legislative and Regulatory Systems


Richard W. Parker 


University of Connecticut School of Law

Alberto Alemanno 


HEC Paris; NYU School of Law

May 15, 2014

European Commission, Brussels, May 2014 

Abstract:      
The aim of this independent report commissioned by the EU Commission is to inform the EU-US Transatlantic Trade and Investment negotiations on enhanced regulatory coherence and cooperation. It provides negotiators, stakeholders and the public with a comparative overview of the US and EU legislative and regulatory processes in their current form, highlighting differences and similarities. Special emphasis is placed on impact assessment/cost benefit analysis, stakeholder consultations and international regulatory cooperation.
Number of Pages in PDF File: 69

Keywords: TTIP, transatlantic regulatory cooperation, rulemaking, international trade, EU, US, regulatory convergence, regulatory coherence, regulatory compatibility, notice-and-comment, comitology, delegated acts, implementing acts, judicial review

On Policing Article 2 TEU Compliance – Reverse Solange and Systemic Infringements Analyzed


Dimitry Kochenov 


University of Groningen - Faculty of Law

May 17, 2014

XXXIII Polish Yearbook of International Law 2014, Forthcoming 

Abstract:      
At this stage of development of EU integration the problems emanating from the ‘crisis of values’ and the poor enforceability of Article 2 TEU have come to the fore in Hungary and elsewhere. The Union is apparently powerless to ensure that it is indeed composed of democratic states based on the rule of law as the Treaties state. The crucial issue for the successful development of EU law in this context is to find an efficient and expedient way to remedy this situation. While a number of scholarly proposals of how to do this has been tabled (besides the Commission’s own ‘pre-Article 7 procedure’ communication), two among them stand out. This paper provides a systemic critical analysis of the two, which most detailed and potentially far-reaching scholarly proposals currently available. The focus is on the ‘Reverse Solange’ proposal by Armin von Bogdandy et al. and on the ‘systemic infringement’ proposal by Kim Lane Scheppele. While both proposals for dealing with the crisis of the Rule of Law are of importance, as they provide valuable starting points in thinking about what to do at this troubling moment of EU integration history, neither of the two is likely to solve the crisis. Placing them in the context of numerous other options which are currently discussed is of key importance for solving the Union’s problems and bringing Hungary and eventual other deviant Member States back on track now and also in the future.

Number of Pages in PDF File: 37

Constitutional Islamization and Human Rights: The Surprising Origin and Spread of Islamic Supremacy in Constitutions


Dawood I. Ahmed 


University of Chicago - Law School

Tom Ginsburg 


University of Chicago Law School

May 20, 2014

Virginia Journal of International Law, Forthcoming
U of Chicago, Public Law Working Paper No. 477 

Abstract:      
The events of the Arab Spring and recent military coup in Egypt have highlighted the central importance of the constitutional treatment of Islam. Many constitutions in the Muslim world incorporate clauses that make Islamic law supreme or provide that laws repugnant to Islam will be void. The prevalence and impact of these “Islamic supremacy clauses” is of immense importance for constitutional design — not just for Muslim countries but also for U.S. foreign policy in the region, which became engaged in the issue during constitution-writing in Afghanistan and Iraq. However, to date, there has been no systematic or empirical examination of these clauses. Many questions remain unexplored: Where did these clauses originate? How have they spread? Are they anti-democratic impositions? What determines their adoption in national constitutions?

This Article fills this gap. Relying on an original dataset based on the coding of all national constitutions since 1789 and case studies from four countries — Iran, Afghanistan, Egypt and Iraq — it traces the origin and adoption of Islamic supremacy clauses since their first appearance in Iran in 1907. We make three major, counterintuitive claims: First, we argue that the repugnancy clause — the most robust form of Islamic supremacy clause — has its origins in British colonial law, and indeed, that all forms of Islamic supremacy are more prevalent in former British colonies than in other states in the region. Second, we argue that in many cases, these clauses are not only popularly demanded, but are also first introduced into their respective jurisdictions during moments of liberalization and modernization. Third, contrary to the claims of those who assume that the constitutional incorporation of Islam will be antithetical to human rights, we demonstrate that almost every instance of “Constitutional Islamization” is accompanied by an expansion, and not a reduction, in the rights provided by the constitution. Indeed, constitutions which incorporate Islamic supremacy clauses are even more rights-heavy than constitutions of other Muslim countries which do not incorporate these clauses. We explain the incidence of this surprising relationship using the logic of coalitional politics.

These findings have significant normative implications. On a broader level, our work supports the view of scholars who argue that the constitutional incorporation of Islam is not only compatible with the constitutional incorporation of basic principles of liberal democracy, but that more democracy in the Muslim world may mean more Islam in the public sphere; in fact, we find that more democratic countries are not necessarily any less likely to adopt Islamic supremacy clauses. Our findings also suggest that outsiders monitoring constitution-making in majority Muslim countries who argue for the exclusion of Islamic clauses are focused on a straw man; not only are these clauses popular, but they are nearly always accompanied by a set of rights provisions that could advance basic values of liberal democracy. We accordingly suggest that constitutional advisors should focus more attention on the basic political structures of the constitution, including the design of constitutional courts and other bodies that will engage in interpretation, than on the Islamic provisions themselves.

Number of Pages in PDF File: 87

lunedì 5 maggio 2014





Dear friends and colleagues,

we are pleased to announce the contents of this STALS newsletter.

STALS Papers

Gianluigi Palombella, “Quo isti Europa? Relative Movement and the Lens of
Transformation”
STALS Research Paper N. 2/2014
http://www.stals.sssup.it/files/palombella%202%202014.pdf

Giuseppe Martinico, “EU Crisis and Constitutional Mutations: A Review
Article”
STALS Research Paper N. 3/2014”
http://www.stals.sssup.it/files/martinico%20crisis.pdf

STALS Events

15 May 2014
11.00 -13.00 (saletta riunioni 6)
"Constitutional Reasoning" e Corte di giustizia dell'Unione europea
http://stals.sssup.it/files/itzcovich.pdf

16 May 2014
16.00-18.00 (saletta riunioni 6)
Fact-Finding before the International Court of Justice: How to Restyle the

Respected Old Lady
http://stals.sssup.it/files/devaney.pdf


SSSUP Events

14 May 2014
11.00-13.30 (aula 6)

Cittadino e opinione pubblica in Europa: un dibattito
http://stals.sssup.it/sssup-events

All the best from Pisa,

the Editors